Abstract
This paper evaluates nonlinear free vibrations of Levy plates using WeakForm variational principle in algebraic polynomial displacement functions. The energy functional of the plate problem was formulated using WeakForm variational technique on the integral function of the Von Karman thin plate differential equations. The displacement functions were developed based on static deflection configurations of orthogonal beam network. The process of repeated direct integration on compatibility equation was used to determine the algebraic expressions for stress function. The amplitude of deflection which directly influences the geometric nonlinearity of the plate was determined using integration process on energy functional based on static equilibrium equations. The modal combination method was used to develop the stiffness and mass matrices respectively from the expressions of energy functional based on dynamic equilibrium equations. The numerical values of amplitudes of deflection at various aspect ratios were computed. Also, the first four nonlinear natural frequencies at various aspect ratios were numerically computed. The validation of the present study’s results using the results from previous work found in literature shows satisfactory convergence, with an absolute mean error of 0.186 %. Conclusively, the application of WeakForm variational principle in polynomial displacement functions provides satisfactory approximation to nonlinear dynamic analysis of Levy plates.
1. Introduction
A levy plate in the context of this paper refers to any rectangular plate in which at least two opposite edge conditions are simply supported; and any of the two remaining edge conditions can either be clamped, simply supported or free. Engineering applications of levy plates are widely found in bridges, houses, marine structures, vehicular structures and airspace structures. In practice, almost all the rectangular plates engaged in the construction of these structures are classified as thinwalled structural components. Sequel to their thinness, the plates are often prone to large deformation in their engineering applications due to the influence of external disturbances. Consequently, the appropriate engineering analysis that is capable of simulating the actual response of thin rectangular plates to external disturbances must be the one formulated based on nonlinear mathematical model. However, the implication of using nonlinear mathematical model to determine the plate response is that the resulting nonlinear differential equations of equilibrium are likely going to impose complex mathematical challenges, and sometimes the closedform solutions are absent. This problem is readily observed in the case of plates with mixed boundary conditions (majority of levy plates), which exhibit discontinuities in the edge supports [1].
For the fact that the resulting nonlinear differential equations from nonlinear method of analysis are tedious to tackle, approximation mathematical models have been developed to ameliorate the problem. Consequently, many of the investigators on large amplitude of vibrations of rectangular thin plates apply different approximation techniques to tackle the problem of nonlinear vibrations of thin rectangular plates.
1.1. Related works
Engineering analysis of thin rectangular plates based on large amplitude of vibrations has for decade now posed interesting and challenging research fields. A number of approximation techniques have been developed for the purposes of investigating into large amplitude of vibrations of thin rectangular plates. [2] used Herrmann equations of motion in Galerkin technique to study the effect of initially applied stress on the nonlinear vibrations of flat plate. Finite element methods were used by [35] to investigate into large amplitude of vibrations of rectangular plates. Analytical technique on dynamic analogue of Von Karman differential equations was employed by [6] to investigate the effect of initial geometric imperfections and inplane boundary conditions on the large amplitude of vibrations of angle and cross ply rectangular thin plates. [7] used levy solutions to study the vibration behaviour of multispan rectangular plates. A combination of static and dynamic methodproblem solving was used by [8] to investigate geometrically nonlinear free vibration of square plates with various boundary conditions. Second order asymptotic method was employed by [9] to investigate the effect of geometric imperfections on the amplitude of nonlinear vibrations of thin rectangular plates that were parametrically excited. A multiple scale method was used by [10] to investigate the nonlinear vibration of rectangular plates. Meshfree least squaresbased finite difference method was used by [11] to investigate large amplitude of vibrations of arbitrarily shaped thin plates. [12] used first order finite element theory to study free vibration of composite plates. A combination of Hamilton principle and Galerkin method was used by [13] to investigate nonlinear dynamic response of a simply supported functionally graded rectangular plate under the timedependent thermalmechanical loads. Also, [14] used finite strip formulation to study nonlinear free vibration of plates. Furthermore, [15] used analytical technique, numerical and experimental analysis to study vibration behaviour of laminated composite plates under thermomechanical loading. The GalerkinVlasov method was used by [16] to obtain solution of free harmonic vibration of simply supported Kirchhoff plate.
1.2. Statement of problem and objectives
The energy methods have been proven to be very powerful for solving structural problems, especially those ones subjected to large deformations and large amplitude of vibrations. In analytical energy approach, the commonest approximation techniques appearing in most technical literature are the Hamilton’s energy principle, the classical direct variational principle in Ritz method, and the residual energy method in Galerkin approach. Also, the most commonly used displacement functions are the trigonometric functions, either in the form of single or double Fourier series. There is need therefore, to explore other simple but accurate approximation techniques to be used in formulating energy functional for structural problems.
The primary objective of this study is to apply WeakForm variational principle in formulating energy functional for nonlinear rectangular plate problem. The secondary objective is to develop and apply algebraic polynomial shape functions admissible to various levy plate boundary conditions.
2. Theoretical formulations
Fig. 1 shows a rectangular thin isotropic plate of levy type in which the edges $x=$ 0 and $x=a$ are parallel and simply supported.
The boundary conditions of the edges $y=$ 0 and $y=b$ are arbitrary; and each of them can either be clamped, simply supported or free. The plate is invariant in engineering properties of Young modulus $E$ and Poisson’s ratio $\mu $, and it has constant mass density $\rho $. The plate lateral dimensions are defined by $a$ and $b$ as the length and width respectively.
Fig. 1A rectangular plate showing at least two edges parallel and simply supported
2.1. Formulation of energy functional
The Weakform variational principle is used to formulate the energy functional of the plate problems. The plate is assumed to be thin; and it satisfies the integral function of Von Karman’s thin plate differential equations. The analogous Von Karman’s thin plate differential equations of motion are as expressed in Eqs. (12):
where $E$ is Young modulus of plate materials; $w$ is displacement functions; $F$ is Airy’s stress functions; $t$ is plate thickness; $\rho $ is mass density of plate materials; $q$ is uniformly applied lateral load; $\ddot{w}$ is second derivative of $w$ with respect to time $T$; $D$ is flexural rigidity of the plate
Let $V\left(x,y\right)$ be defined as weighting function which is admissible to boundary conditions of the levy plates. Then the variational statement is applied on the integral functions of Eq. (1) as expressed in Eq. (3):
where $D$ is defined as expressed in Eq. (4):
where $\mu $ is Poisson’s ratio.
Let $K$ be the reciprocal of $D$ as given by Eq. (5):
Integration by parts is exercised on Eq. (3) to trade differentiation from $w$ and $F$ to $V\left(x,y\right)$, and after simplification yields the expressions as given in Eq. (6):
where:
The expressions obtained in Eq. (6) contain three identically satisfied expressions: the functional of the plate problem, which is the integrand as contained in the squared bracket; and two natural boundary conditions, which are the integrands as contained in the curl brackets. These natural boundary conditions are identically satisfied at the boundary of the plate, and as such they are dropped in the further analysis in this work.
By assuming that the plate vibrates harmonically and performs sinusoidal time response, the inertia term is simplified, and the expression for the functional is as expressed in Eq. (8):
Furthermore, for a free vibration analysis, the lateral load $q$ is disregarded so that Eq. (8) is simplified as expressed in Eq. (9):
where:
The expression of Eq. (9) is a generic functional for dynamics of rectangular thin plates.
2.2. The boundary conditions
The analysis of geometrically nonlinear thin rectangular plates requires the consideration of both the outofplane and inplane boundary conditions. In this study, the levy plates of simply supportedclampedsimply supportedclamped (SCSC), simply supportedclampedsimply supportedsimply supported (SCSS), simply supportedsimply supportedsimply supportedsimply supported (SSSS), simply supportedclampedsimply supportedfree (SCSF), and simply supportedsimply supportedsimply supportedfree (SSSF) rectangular plates respectively are considered. The general boundary conditions with respect to these rectangular plates are stated as given in Eq. (1123) [1719]:
The SCSC Rectangular plate:
The SCSS rectangular plate:
The SSSS rectangular plate:
The SCSF rectangular plate:
The SSSF rectangular plate:
2.3. Determination of specially energy functional
From the generic energy functional of Eq. (9), the specially energy functional with respect to any set of rectangular boundary conditions is determined by applying the general boundary conditions of Eq. (1123). Thus, the specially energy functional (SEF) for SCSC rectangular plate is given as expressed in Eq. (24):
The SEF for SCSS and SSSS rectangular plates is as given by Eq. (25):
And the SEF for SCSF and SSSF rectangular plates is as given in Eq. (26):
2.4. Development of displacement functions
Fig. 2 shows a levy plate consisting of an idealized series of orthogonal beam network in $x$ and $y$directions. It is assumed that each beam element running along any coordinate direction is a good representative of other series of beam elements that run along the same direction.
Fig. 2A Levy plate showing a series of orthogonal beam network and deflection configurations
Let $w\left(x\right)$ and $w\left(y\right)$ denote the algebraic polynomial displacement functions in $x$ and $y$directions as expressed in Eq. (27) and Eq. (28) respectively:
where ${c}_{i}$ and ${d}_{j}$ are undetermined coefficients.
Numerically, it has been proven that a fiveterm polynomials provides necessary and sufficient satisfaction for completeness as shape functions for a beam element. Therefore, the value of $r$ in the summation is four. The outofplane boundary conditions for clamped edge, simply supported edge and free edge are as expressed in Eq. (29), Eq. (30) and Eq. (31) respectively:
where $w\left(\bullet ,\bullet \right)$ represents deflection function, $w\text{'}\left(\bullet ,\bullet \right)$, $w\text{'}\text{'}\left(\bullet ,\bullet \right)$ and $w\text{'}\text{'}\text{'}\left(\bullet ,\bullet \right)$ represent first, second and third derivatives with respect to the coordinates respectively.
Suppose Fig. 2 depicts a levy plate of SCSC rectangular plate, then the deflection along $x$direction is expressed as given in Eq. (32):
By applying the boundary conditions of Eq. (30) in Eq. (32), and subsequently carrying out simplification, gives Eq. (33):
However, to account for series of beam mode shapes running along $y$direction, Eq. (33) is modified as shown in Eq. (34):
Similarly suppose the edges Eqs. (2) and (4) of Fig. 2 are clamped, then the polynomial expression is as expressed in Eq. (35):
By applying the boundary conditions of Eq. (29) in Eq. (35) and after simplifying, yields Eq. (36):
Also, to account for series of beam mode shapes running along $x$direction, Eq. (36) is modified as shown in Eq. (37):
where $m$, $n=$ 1, 2, 3, …
The rectangular plate static mode shape is the product of Eq. (34) and Eq. (37) as expressed in Eq. (38):
where ${A}_{mn}$ is as expressed in Eq. (39):
The parameter ${A}_{mn}$ is the amplitude of deflection function. Thus Eq. (38) is the static algebraic polynomial displacement function for SCSC rectangular plate. The same procedure is used to develop the static algebraic polynomial mode shapes for SCSS, SSSS, SCSF and SSSF rectangular plates; and they are as expressed in Eq. (4043) respectively:
2.5. The stress function
One of the unknown parameters in the expression for the energy functional is the Airy’s stress function $F$. In this work, direct integration process on compatibility Eq. (2) is used to determine the expression for stress function. Thus, a repeated integration process on the right hand side of Eq. (2) is performed four times with respect to $x$coordinate; and then four times with respect to $y$coordinate as expressed in Eq. (44):
where ${\int}_{x}^{.}=\int \left(\bullet \right)dx$ and${\int}_{y}^{.}=\int \left(\bullet \right)dy$; and for $m=$ 1, 2 and $n=$ 1, 2, 3.
In this study, the following designations for describing mode shapes are adopted: for $m=n=$ 1, then $w\left(\mathrm{1,1}\right)$ denotes the first mode shape; for $m=$1 and $n=$ 2, then $w\left(\mathrm{1,2}\right)$ denotes the second mode shape; for $m=$ 1 and $n=$ 3, then $w\left(\mathrm{1,3}\right)$ denotes the third mode shape; and for $m=$ 2 and $n=$ 2, then $w\left(\mathrm{2,2}\right)$ denotes the fourth mode shape. For instance, at mode 1, the mode shape with respect to SCSC rectangular plate is as given in Eq. (45):
Therefore, the corresponding algebraic stress function ${F}_{11}$ with respect to SCSC rectangular plate evaluated using Eq. (44) is as expressed in Eq. (46):
where $Q$ is as expressed in Eq. (47):
At any specified mode, the corresponding stress function is determined by substituting the corresponding mode shape into compatibility equation of Eq. (2); and then integrated by using Eq. (44).
2.6. Determination of amplitude of deflection
The frequency of natural vibration is a function of the rigidity parameter of the plate; and under large deflection, the plate analysis is shifted from rigid to flexible plate analysis, and the frequency depends on how much the system deviates from equilibrium position (amplitude of deflection).
The amplitude of deflection ${A}_{mn}$ is an unknown parameter associated with the mode shape; and to determine the amplitude of deflection, the expression for mode shape is appropriately substituted into the energy functional equation. The inertia parameter in the energy equations of Eq. (2426) is replaced with the lateral load parameter $\left(KVq\right).$
In this work, the mode shapes to be considered for any given set of plate boundary conditions are $w\left(\mathrm{1,1}\right)$, $w\left(\mathrm{1,2}\right)$, $w\left(\mathrm{1,3}\right)$ and $w\left(\mathrm{2,2}\right)$; and the amplitudes of deflection to be determined are ${A}_{11}$, ${A}_{12}$, ${A}_{13}$ and ${A}_{22}$ respectively. It is assumed that the problem system is selfadjoint. Consequently, the weighting function $V$ in the energy functional is interchanged with the deflection function $w$ without loss in generality. For instance, by letting $V=w\left(\mathrm{1,1}\right)$, the integral expression for evaluating the amplitude of deflection ${A}_{11}$ for SCSC rectangular plate is as shown in Eq. (48):
By carrying out double integration process and simplification on Eq. (48), an expression that simulates the Duffing’s type of equation is obtained as shown in Eq. (49):
where $\beta =b/a$. The solution of Eq. (49) yields three roots in terms of ${A}_{11}$ which are characterized with two complex roots and a real root. The real root of Eq. (49) in terms of ${A}_{11}$ is given as expressed in Eq. (50):
where:
Thus, the expressions for ${A}_{12}$, ${A}_{13}$, and ${A}_{22}$ are determined using the same procedure.
2.7. Determination of stiffness and mass matrices
The vibration of each mode shape of a rectangular plate consists of a product of two perpendicular motions in $x$ and $y$coordinates respectively. During natural vibrations, there exist modal interactions among different modes. Consequently, in this work, the mode shape $w$ and the weighting function $V$ are interactively combined to effect these modal interactions. Thus, to determine the natural frequencies, the expressions representing the energy functional of Eq. (2426) are invoked and modified in accordance with these modal interactions as expressed in Eq. (5658) respectively:
where ${F}_{V}$ and ${F}_{w}$ are the stress functions associated with mode shapes corresponding to weighting function and displacement function respectively. For instance, to determine the stiffness component ${k}_{11}$ at first mode, let $V=w=w\left(\mathrm{1,1}\right)\text{;}$ to determine the stiffness component ${k}_{21}={k}_{12}$, let $V=w\left(\mathrm{1,2}\right)$ and $w=w\left(\mathrm{1,1}\right)$; to determine the stiffness component ${k}_{31}={k}_{13}$, let $V=w\left(\mathrm{1,3}\right)$ and $w=w\left(\mathrm{1,1}\right)$; to determine the stiffness component ${k}_{41}={k}_{14}$, let $V=w\left(\mathrm{2,2}\right)$ and $w=w\left(\mathrm{1,1}\right)$ and so on. For instance, the mode shapes for SCSC plate are as expressed in Eqs. (5962):
Then the stiffness matrix for SCSC rectangular plate is determined using the expressions given in Eqs. (6367):
The resulting stiffness matrix is given as expressed in Eq. (68):
The same procedure is used to develop other required stiffness matrices for SCSS, SSSS, SCSF and SSSF respectively. In similar approach, the right hand side (RHS) of Eq. (56), Eq. (57) and Eq. (58) respectively will yield the mass matrices after due integration process. Thus, for SCSC rectangular plate, the mass matrix is determined by using expressions given in Eqs. (6972):
The resulting mass matrix is as given in Eq. (73):
The same approach is used to develop the mass matrices for SCSS, SSSS, SCSF and SSSF respectively.
3. Numerical evaluation and discussion of results
Natural vibrations of rectangular isotropic plates under geometrical nonlinearity are studied in this paper using weakform variational principle. Numerical evaluations are required for adequate validation of the results of the present study with the results found in existing literature. The plate parameters used in this study are: $E=$ 10.92 MPa, $\rho =$ 100 kgm^{3}, $\mu =$ 0.3, $a=$ 1.0 m, $t=$ 0.01 m, $b=$ open, and $\beta =b/a$ ,which were previously used by [3, 11, 20, 21] in their separate studies using different approximation techniques. Thus, by using aspect ratio, $\beta =1$, these parameters were appropriately substituted and the numerical values for the elements in the stiffness matrix of Eq. (68) are as given in Eq. (74):
Similarly, by substituting these parameters appropriately, the numerical values for the elements in the mass matrix of Eq. (73) are as given in Eq. (75):
In the matrix manipulation, suppose the difference between $\left[\mathbf{K}\right]$ and $\left[\mathbf{B}\right]$ is $\left[\mathbf{A}\right]$, then:
The determinant of $\left[\mathbf{A}\right]$ is thus:
For nontrivial solution of the eigenfunction, Eq. (77) is set equal to zero, as expressed in Eq. (78):
The expression of Eq. (78) can be simplified numerically by premultiplying Eq. (78) by the inverse of Eq. (75) as expressed in Eq. (79):
The result of the manipulation of Eq. (79) yields an expression as given in Eq. (80):
where $R$ is $R={\omega}^{2}.$
The solution of the resulting quartic algebraic equation in terms of R and subsequently in terms of $\omega $ gives the nonlinear natural frequencies of vibration of the rectangular SCSC plate at aspect ratio equal to one. Therefore, by carrying out the same procedure with respect to each of the SCSS, SSSS, SCSF and SSSF rectangular plates respectively yields the desired natural frequencies for the respective rectangular plate up to first four lowest natural frequencies.
However, Table 1 presents the numerical values of the variation of the amplitudes of plate deflection with aspect ratios for the SCSC, SCSS, SSSS, SCSF and SSSF rectangular plates. The amplitudes of deflection are the measures of the rigidity characteristics of rectangular plates; and under geometrical nonlinearity of rectangular plates, these geometric characteristics shift from rigid to flexible plate conditions [21]. The amplitudes of deflection are strong parameters that affect the nonlinear flexural frequencies of rectangular plates based on large deflection.
From Table 1, it was observed that the amplitudes of deflection for the SCSC, SCSS, SSSS and SSSF rectangular plates exhibit hardspring type with the aspect ratios; but with the exception of the amplitudes of deflection of the third mode of the SSSF rectangular plate boundary conditions, which exhibit softspring type. On the other hand, it was observed that the amplitudes of deflection for the SCSF rectangular plate boundary conditions exhibit entirely softspring type with the aspect ratios.
Also, Table 2 presents the numerical values of nonlinear natural frequencies for the SCSC, SCSS, SSSS, SCSF and SSSF rectangular plates based on the above given plate parameters at various aspect ratios.
Table 1Variation of amplitudes of deflection with aspect ratios
Boundary condition  Amplitude of deflection, ${A}_{mn}$  
Mode  Aspect ratio, $\beta $  
$\beta =$ 0.25  $\beta =$ 0.50  $\beta =$ 0.75  $\beta =$ 1.0  $\beta =$ 1.25  $\beta =$ 1.50  
SCSC  ${A}_{11}$  0.0063  0.0919  0.3960  0.9779  1.6535  2.1545 
${A}_{12}$  0.0074  0.1102  0.4925  1.2911  2.3935  3.4001  
${A}_{13}$  0.0064  0.0974  0.4527  1.2603  2.5691  4.1174  
${A}_{22}$  0.0130  0.1863  0.7711  1.8036  3.0012  4.0434  
SCSS  ${A}_{11}$  0.0061  0.0824  0.3160  0.6845  1.0382  1.2800 
${A}_{12}$  0.0054  0.0760  0.3106  0.7364  1.2454  1.6731  
${A}_{13}$  0.0032  0.0477  0.2116  0.5574  1.0770  1.6642  
${A}_{22}$  0.0094  0.1242  0.4556  0.9455  1.4380  1.8363  
SSSS  ${A}_{11}$  0.0057  0.0664  0.2121  0.3788  0.4955  0.5639 
${A}_{12}$  0.0034  0.0466  0.1837  0.4140  0.6552  0.8314  
${A}_{13}$  0.0020  0.0287  0.1253  0.3220  0.6009  0.8879  
${A}_{22}$  0.0059  0.0750  0.2604  0.5091  0.7352  0.9036  
SCSF  ${A}_{11}$  11.4724  4.2488  2.8316  2.3019  2.0428  1.8960 
${A}_{12}$  4.8839  1.6481  1.0031  0.7499  0.6163  0.5327  
${A}_{13}$  7.1802  2.1422  1.1845  0.8296  0.6509  0.5432  
${A}_{22}$  9.8596  3.6792  2.4892  2.0541  1.8455  1.7292  
SSSF  ${A}_{11}$  0.0159  0.1105  0.2136  0.2743  0.3065  0.3247 
${A}_{12}$  0.0116  0.0926  0.2107  0.3089  0.3768  0.4218  
${A}_{13}$  15.2944  5.3778  3.3720  2.5797  2.1637  1.9087  
${A}_{22}$  0.0181  0.1085  0.1924  0.2425  0.2713  0.2887 
Table 2The numerical values of nonlinear natural frequencies of isotropic levy plates at various aspect ratios
Boundary condition  Nonlinear natural frequency, (rad/sec)  
Mode  Aspect ratio, $\beta $  
$\beta =$ 0.25  $\beta =$ 0.50  $\beta =$ 0.75  $\beta =$ 1.0  $\beta =$ 1.25  $\beta =$ 1.50  
SCSC  ${\omega}_{11}$  363.497  95.2656  45.9213  29.0854  23.2362  22.5013 
${\omega}_{12}$  473.004  139.173  80.9642  62.6300  50.0136  42.5369  
${\omega}_{13}$  1013.780  258.712  118.987  70.3803  56.2073  60.022  
${\omega}_{22}$  2049.33  517.789  234.221  135.156  90.7409  71.5289  
SCSS  ${\omega}_{11}$  254.198  69.3414  35.3535  23.7843  19.653  19.2091 
${\omega}_{12}$  366.991  118.946  75.0828  60.2854  42.7581  33.7225  
${\omega}_{13}$  838.929  215.700  100.381  60.6915  54.8403  53.8604  
${\omega}_{22}$  2058.11  520.456  235.745  136.163  90.1307  66.3526  
SSSS  ${\omega}_{11}$  167.815  49.357  27.454  20.5135  19.3654  19.5027 
${\omega}_{12}$  315.027  106.266  69.7313  54.209  40.8385  33.850  
${\omega}_{13}$  713.114  185.143  87.458  57.9053  54.0947  56.3444  
${\omega}_{22}$  1862.55  471.88  214.423  124.733  82.6781  59.174  
SCSF  ${\omega}_{11}$  47.7087  19.6398  14.874  14.3069  13.9204  13.471 
${\omega}_{12}$  116.163  59.5027  43.8963  35.6418  35.2985  35.6283  
${\omega}_{13}$  267.400  78.6609  50.5387  48.853  54.5767 – 0.8225i  53.918 – 5.7295i  
${\omega}_{22}$  991.382  257.027  122.055  76.6943  54.5767 + 0.8225i  53.918 + 5.7295i  
SSSF  ${\omega}_{11}$  0 + 10472.4i  0 + 2588.97i  0 + 1531.26i  0 + 1194.23i  0 + 1044.08i  0 + 965.899i 
${\omega}_{12}$  42.6735  18.8572  14.1528  12.7282  12.169  11.7224  
${\omega}_{13}$  103.498  58.4575  45.4109  33.2682  31.362  33.8029  
${\omega}_{22}$  305.628  86.0388  50.3588  47.5902  46.406  45.960 
From Table 2, it was observed that the nonlinear natural frequencies for the levy plates under investigation exhibit softspring type with aspect ratios, except at the third modes of SCSC and SSSS rectangular plates, which deviated from the norm at aspect ratios 1.25 and 1.5 respectively. Furthermore, it was observed that the SCSF rectangular plate boundary conditions yielded positive realvalued complex conjugate nonlinear natural frequencies at the third and fourth modes in the vicinity of aspect ratios of 1.25 and 1.5 respectively. This exposition significantly doubts the stability of the SCSF rectangular plate boundary conditions at third and fourth modes at aspect ratio greater or equal to 1.25 based on the existence of high positive value of the real part of the complex conjugates. However, at aspect ratios less than or equal to 1.0, the SCSF rectangular plate boundary conditions yielded distinct positive nonlinear natural frequencies at the same third and fourth modes respectively. This exposition signifies that within the vicinity of the identified aspect ratios, the SCSF rectangular plate is stable at the third and fourth modes respectively. Also, from Table 2, it was observed that the SSSF rectangular plate boundary conditions yielded positive pure imaginary nonlinear natural frequencies at the first mode for all the selected aspect ratios, which means that the SSSF plate boundary conditions exhibits critical behaviour at the first mode, otherwise it is said to be merely stable. This exposition signifies that in the geometrically nonlinear dynamic analysis of SSSF rectangular plate boundary conditions using modal combination approach, the fundamental nonlinear frequency is sought at second mode instead of the first mode visàvis the linear fundamental frequency of the plate boundary conditions.
Table 3 presents the comparison of the nonlinear fundamental frequencies of the present study’s results with the results found in literature. However, the restriction to the use of only the nonlinear fundamental frequencies for the comparison was due to the nonavailability of the results for higher mode nonlinear natural frequencies in almost all the literature reviewed.
Table 3Comparison of Nonlinear fundamental frequencies with results found in literature (β= 1)
Plate properties  Boundary condition  Investigator  Fundamental frequency (rad/s)  Percentage error 
$E=$ 10.92 MPa; $\rho =$ 100 kg/m^{3} $\mu =$ 0.3 $a=$ 1.0 m $b=$ 1.0 m $t=$ 0.01 m  SCSC  Present study  29.0854  
[20]  29.1873  0.349  
[3]  29.2315  0.500  
[11]  29.2627  0.606  
SSSS  Present study  20.5135  
[20]  20.0990  –2.062  
[3]  20.0916  –2.100  
[11]  20.0818  –2.150  
SCSS  Present study  23.7843  
[20]  24.0308  1.026  
[3]  24.0113  0.943  
[11]  23.9717  0.782  
$E=$ 30 GPa $\rho =$ 25 kg/m^{3} $\mu =$ 0.3 $a=$ 10 m $b=$ 10 m $t=$ 0.2 m  SSSS  Present study  422.785  
[23]  421.3570  –0.339  
SCSF  Present study  293.666  
[23]  295.1590  0.506  
SSSF  Present study  261.982  
[23]  261.2294  –0.288 
From Table 3, it was observed from columns 4 and 5 that the present study’s results exhibit lowerbound with respect to the results found in literature for the SCSC, SCSS and SCSF rectangular plates respectively. But in the case of SSSS and SSSF rectangular plates, the present study’s results exhibit upperbound with respect to the results found in literature. Also, from column 5 of Table 3, the calculated absolute mean percentage error is 0.186, which shows that the present study’s results are in good agreement with the results found in literature.
4. Conclusions
This paper evaluates the nonlinear natural frequencies for Levy plates using weakform variational principle in algebraic orthogonal polynomial displacement functions. The nonlinear fundamental frequencies evaluated in this work are in good agreement with the results found in literature that were evaluated using other approximation techniques such as the finite element methods. Therefore, it is hereupon concluded that the efficacy of weakform variational principle technique in dynamic analysis of Levy plates is very satisfactory visàvis other approximation techniques. Also, it is hereunto concluded that the use of algebraic polynomial shape functions in vibration analysis of Levy plates yields satisfactory approximations to all the boundary conditions of the plates. Furthermore, it was observed in this work that the nonlinear natural frequencies for SCSF rectangular plate boundary conditions in the third and fourth modes exhibited positive real valued complex conjugates at aspect ratios 1.25 and 1.50 respectively. Thus, it is here concluded that at aspect ratio greater than or equal to 1.25 in the third and fourth modes respectively, the motions of vibration of SCSF rectangular plate are not stable under geometrically nonlinear conditions. Also, it was observed that the nonlinear natural frequencies in the first mode at various aspect ratios for SSSF rectangular plate exhibited positive pure imaginary values. The exposition here shows that at first mode, the nonlinear motion of vibration for SSSF rectangular plate under modal combination analysis is pole centred, otherwise it is said to exhibit critical behaviour or it is merely stable at the first mode. Therefore, it is here concluded that using modal combination analysis, the nonlinear fundamental frequency for SSSF rectangular plate is ought to be sought in the second mode instead of the usual first mode.
References

Yoowattana T., Chantarawichit P., Vibooljak J., Sompornjaroensuk Y. Accurate approximate and analytical methods for vibration and bending problems of plates: a literature survey. Applied Mathematical Sciences, Vol. 9, Issue 35, 2015, p. 16971719.

Crawford J., Atluri S. Nonlinear vibrations of flat plate with initial stresses. Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 43, Issue 1, 1975, p. 117129.

Rao Raju G. V. I. S., Raju K. K. A finite element formulation for large amplitude flexural vibrations of thin rectangular plates. Computers and Structures, Vol. 6, 1976, p. 163167.

Han W., Petyt M. Geometrically nonlinear vibration analysis of thin, rectangular plates using the hierarchical finite element method – I: The fundamental mode of isotropic plates. Computers and Structures, Vol. 63, Issue 2, 1997, p. 295308.

Singha M. K., Daipa R. Nonlinear vibration of symmetrically laminated composite skew plates by finite element method. International Journal of Nonlinear Mechanics, Vol. 42, 2007, p. 11441152.

Hui D. Softspring nonlinear vibrations of antisymmetrically laminated rectangular plates. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, Vol. 27, Issue 6, 1985, p. 397408.

Xiang Y., Zhao Y. B., Wei G. W. Levy solutions for vibration of multispan rectangular plates. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, Vol. 44, 2002, p. 11951218.

Saha K. N., Misra D., Ghosal S., Pohit G. Nonlinear free vibration analysis of square plates with various boundary conditions. Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 287, 2005, p. 10311044.

Bugaru M., Vasile O. Nonlinear dynamic behaviour of thin rectangular plates parametrically excited using the asymptotic method, Part 1: Computation of the amplitude. Proceedings of the 10th WSEAS International Conference on Applied Mathematics, Dallas, Texas, USA, 2006, p. 488492.

Shooshtari A., Khadem S. E. A multiple scale method solution for the nonlinear vibration of rectangular plates. Scientia Iranica, Vol. 14, Issue 1, 2007, p. 6471.

Wu W. X., Shu C., Wang C. M. Meshfree least squaresbased finite difference method for large amplitude free vibration analysis of arbitrarily shaped thin plates. Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 317, 2008, p. 955974.

Lynda B., Fayçal M. A first order finite element theory for free vibration of composite plates. International Review of Mechanical Engineering, Vol. 5, Issue 3, 2011, p. 459464.

Hao Y. X., Zhang W., Yang J., Li S. Y. Nonlinear dynamic response of a simply supported rectangular functionally graded material plate under the timedependent thermalmechanical loads. Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, Vol. 25, Issue 7, 2011, p. 16371646.

Hashemi S., Jaberzadeh E. A finite strip formulation for nonlinear free vibration of plates. 15th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, 2012.

Jameel A. N., Hussien R. M. Vibration analysis of laminated composite plate under thermomechanical loading. Journal of Engineering, Vol. 20, Issue 2, 2014, p. 118135.

Mama B. O., Onah H. N., Ike C. C., Osadebe N. N. Solution of free harmonic vibration equation of simply supported Kirchhoff plate by GalerkinVlasov method. Nigerian Journal of Technology, Vol. 36, Issue 2, 2017, p. 361365.

Chia C. Y. Nonlinear Analysis of Plates. McGrawHill International Book Company, USA, 1980.

Szilard R. Theories and Applications of Plate Analysis. John Wiley and Sons, USA, 2004.

Amabili M. Nonlinear Vibrations and Stability of Shells and Plates. Cambridge University Press, New York, USA, 2008.

Mei C. Finite element displacement method for large amplitude free flexural vibrations of beams and plates. Computers and Structures, Vol. 3, 1973, p. 163174.

Wah T. Large amplitude flexural vibration of rectangular plates. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, Vol. 5, 1963, p. 425438.

Vol’mir A. S. The Nonlinear Dynamics of Plates and Shells. National Technical Information Services, U. S. Department of Commerce, 1974.

Silva F. M. A., Pinho F. A. X., Delprado Z. J. G., Goncalves P. D. On the Galerkiniterative method to the nonlinear vibrations of rectangular plates. 10th Conferencia Brasileria de Dinamica, Controle e Aplicacoes, 2011, p. 140143.